Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

No, I believe the term is "parents don't want 8 year olds getting access to tits, violence and gore"

Given that kids need a device for school in a lot of areas (mine included) and the tools for stopping kids getting either access or bombarded by such stuff are either shit, require deep technical knowledge, or predatory, I can see why people are asking for it.

I presently hate the current system of handing over biometric data in exchange for tits. I don't want some shading startup having my biometrics so that when they go bust, pivot or get hacked, can be used to steal my stuff.

The middle ground is a system that _normal_ people can us to make sure kids who have access to devices can't easily access nefarious shit.

None of that is useful idiots.

When it get fun is the all or nothing crowd. The internet is going to be age gated, whether you like it or not. If you continue to go "INTERNET MUST BE FREEEEEEEE" without accepting that the tools that the populace _want_ don't exist means you get porn bans, or worse.





I think there's probably a middle way without going as far as "biometric data in exchange for tits"

I'm in the UK and so far the only thing I've noticed age wise is Reddit asked me for a webcam selfie, which could easily have been faked by a kid with an accomplice but if the aim of this is to stop actual vulnerable kids that kind of thing is maybe enough. If they are with it enough to use VPNs and stuff they are probably old enough to see porn etc.

Like in the old days people used to avoid the kids looking at porn by putting the porno mags on a high shelf so they couldn't reach them. I don't think you need passport control level ID for this kind of thing.


> I don't think you need passport control level ID for this kind of thing.

I 100% whole heartedly agree.

For uk mobile ISPs there is already a system that stopped most of the nasty stuff from getting past. It was pretty difficult to circumvent, hence why I turned it off for me. If that could have been rolled out wider, with an account password for turning it off, that would have been more than enough.


Webcam selfies are still anonymity destroying. I have a better idea: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46162159



Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: