Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | xvector's commentslogin

This is just a case of mass social psychosis. Claude is the same as it has ever been. Just look at historical benchmarks: https://marginlab.ai/trackers/claude-code-historical-perform...

This mindset trivializes the immense achievements of "the common man" over the course of millennia.

Many of those achievements were achieved through physical violence. The 5-day work week, for example. We don't work 7 days because people kept shooting bosses until the bosses agreed to compromise on 5 days.

We'd have never progressed as a species with your mentality. Change is painful and it's part and parcel of progress.

Humans would be suffering far more today if we weren't willing to accept short term pains for progress.


> We'd have never progressed as a species with your mentality.

Please avoid swipes like this on HN. The guidelines make it clear we're trying for something better here. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html


Change and progress like the people of France deciding they had enough of injustice and nobles' impunity, then? A little short-term pain for social progress? We agree.

Look where France is now. Can't afford their own retirement.

If that's the worst problem they have, that still sounds like things worked out pretty well compared to most places.

That sounds suspiciously like a "ends justify the means" argument.

It's easy to say we need to be willing to accept short term pains when it's someone else who has to bear the brunt of them.


Are you willing to stand by this argument and give up your career?

Will you eat your words when major vuln disclosures come out 3-4 months from now?

Will you eat your words when you find out major vuln disclosures have been happening for decades?

They obviously meant on an unprecedented scale.

Sure, and healthy skepticism before proof is a sign of wisdom.

Which makes taking claims from companies at face value…?


And there's a reason they've achieved precisely zero penetration amongst normies.

A chat app is useless if your friends and family won't use it.


I've actually had good luck getting friends and family on Matrix, after they'd previously used either Facebook Messenger or Hangouts.

It's an LLM.

Yet more AI slop on HN

The post misunderstands how the permission system works.

Giving access to a file via the Open and Save panel is an explicit declaration of consent.

Because the panel is provided by OS itself, the app doesn't get access to the item until the user has selected a folder or file through that panel.


No, this is definitely a bug. The Privacy and Security panel is part of Settings, which is definitely part of the OS. Saying the Open and Save panel somehow has priority suggests that the Privacy and Security panel is not looking at the same parameters as the Open and Save panel, ergo a bug.

It’s not a bug and that is clear if you don’t use the documents folder as your example. When granting specific access it is not the same system as when granting general Documents folder access.

The UI just doesn’t reflect this.


> The UI just doesn’t reflect this.

That's the bug. Either that or MacOS has two separate/distinct mechanisms for managing permissions, which would be a huge security flaw.


MacOS has two distinct mechanisms. One gates access to Desktop, Documents, etc. for general access. The other grants access through the Open dialog. The open dialog is always superior because it's consent for a specific location.

Just because agents aren't immune to prompt injection doesn't make it so that they aren't fantastically capable

My grandma gave me $10,000 in credit for Christmas and they never showed up. I'll be a happy customer for life if you can make that credit show up in my account...

It only has a ~1 in 20,000 chance of working but at scale it'll go through!


Most big tech companies have access to the model, you can absolutely "validate their claims" or talk to someone that can.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: