Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I think people have a bit of a popular misconception about the Explorer advertising thing. What's happening is that MS is adding a banner to Explorer advertising paid OneDrive subscriptions.

I totally agree that it's massively inappropriate, but I do think that most people are imagining third-party advertising which is not what's happening - a lot of people might not consider the current situation to be an "ad" necessarily since it is pushing a subscription for OneDrive, a Microsoft product that you already have installed. It's more of an in-app purchase kind of offer.



I don't particular care who is trying to sell me shit in the file manager, I care that shit is being sold in the file manager.

In an operating system I paid $100 for. Unacceptable.


The shit being sold in the file manager is... space in the cloud for your files. Which is managed by the file manager.


Which I already paid for as part of the operating system. If they want to advertise to me, they can give me my money back.


Yeah I don't understand why people are freaking out about this. I know the icon is there, but I never "see" it and I'll never click on it..

So who cares..


If this is all it is, then it is not unprecedented. I remember that Windows 95 did something similar with MSN (which at that time was also a dialup service).


Yeah, I recently installed Windows 95 in a VM to run some old software and I was actually quite surprised at how hard it pushes MSN - the "connect to the internet" wizard it presents basically asks if you're on a LAN and, if you say no, tells you to call MSN to sign up.


As-is, I don't think it's a big deal. This is a slippery slope though. Look at what cable television has become. You pay for the product and they shove advertisements down your throat. Satellite radio is doing the same thing.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: