This blog post exposes the badness of SMS-based recovery. I think other recovery options such as Yubikey aren't ideal either, as a Yubikey may simply stop working and you're completely locked out. The specific situation the author of the blog post isn't dramatic - he can't receive SMS - personal decision to avoid roaming charges.
But in all seriousness, if there's an authentication recovery standard, it should serve all people including those who are in seriously difficult circumstances (e.g. homeless or ill). The question then is what should recovery look like in those cases.
To me it looks like good old recovery code on paper is the best solution, as it doesn't depend on ever-changing device ports, or hardware malfunction due to lack of use long-term (such as 10-15 years).
I wonder whether authentication apps nowdays address that aspect and make and I kinda doubt so (i.e. can you print out a QR code with all account information in your typical TOTP app?).
But in all seriousness, if there's an authentication recovery standard, it should serve all people including those who are in seriously difficult circumstances (e.g. homeless or ill). The question then is what should recovery look like in those cases.
To me it looks like good old recovery code on paper is the best solution, as it doesn't depend on ever-changing device ports, or hardware malfunction due to lack of use long-term (such as 10-15 years).
I wonder whether authentication apps nowdays address that aspect and make and I kinda doubt so (i.e. can you print out a QR code with all account information in your typical TOTP app?).