Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin
New US curb on high-skill immigrant workers ignores evidence of its likely harms (piie.com)
18 points by paulpauper 3 months ago | hide | past | favorite | 9 comments


Are hiring teams responding by favoring US citizens already or is this a “wait and see” sort of thing with no change to hiring?


Citizens are always favored. It costs way more money, lawyers, time and paperwork to hire someone on a visa. HR hates it.


The word on the street is it was cheaper to hire foreigners than locals. This probably changes that.


I mean they are cheaper initially, but as they gain experience and knowledge they aren’t cheaper than anyone else. The difference is that initial cost saving blocks a lot of people who are already US citizens from developing those skills and knowledge.


One more reason for employers to invest in their local communities now … This comes down to cheap education. The skills can be acquired cheaper abroad. Companies can provide free education now or pay the 100k which is close to the cost of education here.


Yes I mean Trump's entire economic policy agenda domestically is to enact massive corporate taxes for any company that avoids hiring/training Americans to get cheaper labor from abroad. The problem is that the US has basically depended on importing cheap foreign labor from its inception, thats the basic economic model here and the only reason that countries like China or India don't need external immigration is because they already have internal migration. I remember I was taking a taxi in Kochi once and the driver was complaining about all these northern Indian economic migrants displacing local workers because the wages in South India are much higher than in North India. But the US does not have any poor workers or a peasant population. Unfortunately, all those good, cheap workers are going to end up elsewhere now and the west will probably begin to suffer economic slowdown because their workers don't want to get priced out. Eventually all the borders will come down, since they harm competition.


You forgot how beholden the visa holder is, which aside to cost is the other benefit.


doesn't this just increase the desire by companies to hire people remotely in other countries?


WSJ reported today that 100 K fees was basically the bone Lutnick threw at the immigration opponent groups in exchange for their support for the $1 million Trump branded Gold card.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: